SVCT Members' Choice Awards 2004-2005
| Best Female Chorus (Youth) | Christiana Bray (Matron in "Aladdin") |
| Best Male Chorus (Youth) | Michael McGill (Prince, the Artist & ensemble in "Aladdin") |
| Best Female Chorus (Adult) | Marion Pintello (Dot in "Honk") |
| Best Male Chorus (Adult) | Rod Pintello (Greylag in "Honk") |
| Best Actress in a Minor Role (Youth) | Eliza Dean (Jester in "Once Upon a Mattress") |
| Best Actor in a Minor Role (Youth) | Gabriel Hatcher (Iago in "Aladdin") |
| Best Actress in a Minor Role (Adult) | Allyson Finn (the Mute in "The Fantasticks") |
| Best Actor in a Minor Role (Adult) | Dave Leon (Bullfrog in "Honk") |
| Best Supporting Actress (Youth) | Alexandra Mandel (Magic Carpet in "Aladdin") |
| Best Supporting Actor | John Kellett (Genie in "Aladdin") |
| Best Supporting Actress (Adult) | Jennifer Hamilton (Maureen in "Honk") |
| Best Supporting Actor (Adult) | David Sandhu (Cat in "Honk") |
| Best Actress (Youth) | Jessica Brewka (Princess Winnifred in "Once Upon a Mattress") |
| Best Actor (Youth) | Antonio Silva (Prince Dauntless in "Once Upon a Mattress") |
| Best Actress (Adult) | Sandi Lewandowski (Ida in "Honk") |
| Best Actor (Adult) | Lane Grover (Ugly in "Honk") |
| "Moon Over Buffalo" Producers' Award | Rich Kaiser |
| "Once Upon a Mattress" Producers' Award | Rhonda Callen |
| "Honk" Producers' Award | Kae Jenny-Spencer |
| "The Fantasticks" Producers' Award | Beth and Wayne Dewey |
| "Aladdin" Producers' Award | Kim Kehrer |
| Newcomer Award | the Kellett family |
| Rosalie Andrews Technical Award | Stephen Porter |
| Al Bloom Shining Star Award | Beth & Wayne Dewey and Renee O'Hara |
| Outstanding Talent Award | Allyson Finn |
| Gypsy Robe Recipients | |
| "Moon Over Buffalo" | Peter Mandel |
| "Once Upon a Mattress" | Manuel Silva |
| "Honk" | Valerie Valdez |
| "The Fantasticks" | Colleen Chipman |
| "Aladdin" | Jacob Garcia |
| Best Choreographer | April Ouellette ("Aladdin") |
| Best Costumes | Kathy Tom and Amelia Souza-Hatcher ("Aladdin") |
| Best Set Design/Artist | Colleen Chipman and Larry Tom ("Aladdin") |
| Best Make-up Artist | Lisa Kellett ("Aladdin") |
| Best Music Director | Carol Harris ("Honk") |
| Best Vocal Director | Carol Harris ("Honk") |
| Best Director | Colleen Chipman ("Aladdin") |
| Best Show | "Aladdin" (April Ouellette and Jon Reed, producers) |