2011-2012 Members’ Choice Awards

Best Show: The Wizard of Oz
| Award | Recipient | Role | Show |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best Female Ensemble (Youth) | Rebecca Reynolds | Munchkin | The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Male Ensemble (Youth) | A.J. Calisi | Munchkin | The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Actress in a Minor Role (Youth) | Makena McElroy | Lullabye League / Jitterbug | The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Actor in a Minor Role (Youth) | Nicholas Quijano | Lollipop Guild | The Wizard of Oz |
| Carter Sepulveda | Lollipop Guild | The Wizard of Oz | |
| Best Supporting Actress (Youth) | Nicole Chambers | Fern Arable | Charlotte’s Web |
| Best Supporting Actor (Youth) | Andrew Stebbins | Mayor / Monkey | The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Actress in a Leading Role (Youth) | Hana McElroy | Charlotte | Charlotte’s Web |
| Best Actor in a Leading Role (Youth) | Matthew Colbert | Homer Zuckerman | Charlotte’s Web |
| Best Female Ensemble (Teen) | Brittini Bombino | Dena Dream / Dolores Dolores | Damn Yankees |
| Best Male Ensemble (Teen) | Collin Sperry | Ensemble | On the Town |
| Best Actress in a Minor Role (Teen) | Pearl Bass | Flossie | On the Town |
| Best Actor in a Minor Role (Teen) | Zack Goller | Zeke / Crow | The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Supporting Actress (Teen) | Samantha Quijano | Singing Teacher | On the Town |
| Best Supporting Actor (Teen) | Connor Clark | Judge Pitkin W Bridgework | On the Town |
| Best Actress in a Leading Role (Teen) | Pascale Vinkhuyzen | Hildy Esterhazy | On the Town |
| Best Actor in a Leading Role (Teen) | Chris Bezanson | Ozzie | On the Town |
| Best Female Ensemble (Adult) | Myra F. Kaelin | Tree / Jitterbug | The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Male Ensemble (Adult) | Bud Biafore | Winkie Captain | The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Actress in a Minor Role (Adult) | Robin Harris | Miss Almira Gulch | The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Actor in a Minor Role (Adult) | Bill Tindall | Out of Order | |
| Best Supporting Actress (Adult) | Mary Beth Anderson | Wicked Witch of the West | The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Supporting Actor (Adult) | Jason Harris | Mr. Applegate | Damn Yankees |
| Best Actress in a Leading Role (Adult) | Megan Griffin | Dorothy Gale | The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Actor in a Leading Role (Adult) | Travis Blanchard | Scarecrow | The Wizard of Oz |
| Gypsy Robe Recipient | Melodie Knappe | Charlotte’s Web | |
| Jan Lance | The Wizard of Oz | ||
| Sarah Mallette | Damn Yankees | ||
| Haylee Merrill | On the Town | ||
| Bill Tindall | Out of Order | ||
| Producer’s Award | Jim Carrillo | On the Town | |
| Greg Casper | Damn Yankees | ||
| Mark Starrett | Out of Order | ||
| Timer Starrett | Out of Order | ||
| Ray Trimble | The Wizard of Oz | ||
| Becky Kaiser Newcomer Award | Kogan Family | ||
| Al Bloom Shining Star Award | Kel Whisner | ||
| Rosalie Andrews Technical Award | Greg Casper | ||
| Nikki Tom | |||
| Outstanding Talent Award | Terry Sodergren | ||
| Outstanding Service Award | BookSmart | ||
| Best Make-Up and Hair | Tiffany Goller & Jan Lance | The Wizard of Oz | |
| Best Costumer | Michelle Griffin | The Wizard of Oz | |
| Best Set Design and Scenic Artist | Gerry Blanchard, Glynis Crabb & Colleen Tom-Blanchard | The Wizard of Oz | |
| Best Choreographer | Mitzie Imagawa | Damn Yankees | |
| Best Music Director | James Chipman | The Wizard of Oz | |
| Best Vocal Director | James Chipman | The Wizard of Oz | |
| Best Director | Colleen Tom-Blanchard | The Wizard of Oz | |
| Best Show | Jon Szczepaniak & Kathy Tom, Producers | The Wizard of Oz | |