2024-2025 Members’ Choice Awards
Best Musical: The Prom
Best Play: Dear Jack, Dear Louise
—
| Award | Winner | Role | Show |
|---|---|---|---|
| INDIVIDUALS IN A MUSICAL | |||
| Best Actress Ensemble (Youth) | Amelia Bortolussi | Seagull | Finding Nemo, Jr. |
| Best Actress Featured Role (Youth) | Emma Aitken | Crush | Finding Nemo, Jr. |
| Best Actress Supporting Role (Youth) | Annabella Zambataro | Gill | Finding Nemo, Jr. |
| Best Actress Lead Role (Youth) | Dara Hargreaves | Dory | Finding Nemo, Jr. |
| Best Actor Ensemble (Youth) | Graham Bowman | Young Barry | The Prom |
| Best Actor Featured Role (Youth) | Graham Bortolussi | Theo | Pippin |
| Outstanding Performance: Actor Supporting Role (Youth) | Jude Lee | Gurgle | Finding Nemo, Jr. |
| Outstanding Performance: Actor Lead Role (Youth) | Matthew Horta | Marlin | Finding Nemo, Jr. |
| Best Actress Ensemble (Teen) | Brennan Klotzbach | Ensemble | Mean Girls |
| Best Actress Featured Role (Teen) | Miriam Shem-Tov | Featured Dancer | The Prom |
| Best Actress Supporting Role (Teen) | Coraline Christian | Gretchen Weiners | Mean Girls |
| Best Actress Lead Role (Teen) | Klara Klotzbach | Leading Player | Pippin |
| Best Actor Ensemble (Teen) | Oliver Oliphant | Ensemble | Pippin |
| Best Actor Featured Role (Teen) | Miles Casey | Kevin G | Mean Girls |
| Best Actor Supporting Role (Teen) | Ezrah Cortez | Damian | Mean Girls |
| Best Actress Ensemble Role (Adult) | Joyce Bedard | Ensemble | Pippin |
| Best Actress Featured Role (Adult) | Josie Lawson | Berthe | Pippin |
| Best Actress Supporting Role (Adult) | Tressa Bender | King Charles | Pippin |
| Best Actress Lead Role (Adult) | Kaitlyn Scadina | Emma Nolan | The Prom |
| Best Actor Ensemble Role (Adult) | Giacomo Vaccaro | Ensemble | The Prom |
| Best Actor Featured Role (Adult) | Juan Gonzalez | Lewis | Pippin |
| Best Actor Supporting Role (Adult) | Mark Alexander | Principal Hawkins | The Prom |
| Best Actor Lead Role (Adult) | Andy Gonzalez | Pippin | Pippin |
| INDIVIDUALS IN A PLAY | |||
| Best Actress Featured / Ensemble Role | Robin Harris | Mary Meekly | Unnecessary Farce |
| Best Actress Supporting Role | Lauren DeRosa | Mimi Merelli | A Comedy of Tenors |
| Best Actress Lead Role | Megan Griffin | Louise Rabiner | Dear Jack, Dear Louise |
| Best Actor Featured / Ensemble Role | PJ Crocker | Carlo Nucci | A Comedy of Tenors |
| Best Actor Supporting Role | Jery Rosas | Max | A Comedy of Tenors |
| Best Actor Lead Role | Robert Sean Campbell | Jack Ludwig | Dear Jack, Dear Louise |
| LEGACY ROBE RECIPIENTS | Emma Stebbins & Oliver Olson | Finding Nemo, Jr. | |
| Ty Ortega & Richard Yin | Pippin | ||
| Brennan Klotzbach | Mean Girls | ||
| Giacomo Vaccaro & Amanda Fitzgerald | The Prom | ||
| PRODUCERS’ AWARDS | Emi Komatsu | A Comedy of Tenors | |
| Hoiberg Family | Finding Nemo, Jr. | ||
| Marilyn Pifer | Pippin | ||
| Roberta Vinkhuyzen, Stacia Stuart, Brennan Klotzbach, Kia Jones, Kelly Kobata, Jonathan Krantz | Pre-show performers | Dear Jack, Dear Louise | |
| Tim Ahlin | Mean Girls | ||
| Jeff Allison, Peter Mandel & Shachar Shem-Tov | Unnecessary Farce | ||
| Kyle Strenfel & Kelly Kobata | The Prom | ||
| BOARD OF DIRECTORS AWARDS | |||
| Becky Kaiser Newcomer Award | Miguel Ledezma | Music Director | The Prom |
| Outstanding Volunteer Service Award | Bill Tindall | Warehouse Manager | |
| Al Bloom Shining Star Award | Brennan Klotzbach | iRegina George understudy | Mean Girls |
| Marty Cheek Community Service Award | Bullet Wireless | ||
| STAFF AWARDS – PLAY | |||
| Best Set & Scenic Design | Andrew Cummings | Dear Jack, Dear Louise | |
| Best Costume Design | Michelle Griffin | Dear Jack, Dear Louise | |
| Best Director | Andrew Cummings | Dear Jack, Dear Louise | |
| STAFF AWARDS – MUSICAL | |||
| Best Choreographer | Christine Carrillo & Natalie Fitzgibbons | Mean Girls | |
| Best Vocal Director | Terry Sodergren | Pippin | |
| Best Music Director | Miguel Ledezma | The Prom | |
| Best Costume Design | Adrianne Wilkinson | Finding Nemo, Jr. | |
| Best Set & Scenic Design | Gloria Horta | Finding Nemo, Jr. | |
| Best Director | Tressa Bender | The Prom | |
| BEST PLAY | Dear Jack, Dear Louise – Peter Mandel & Emily Shem-Tov, Producers | ||
| BEST MUSICAL | The Prom – Ashley Bortolussi & Emily Shem-Tov, Producers | ||