2025-2026 Members’ Choice Awards
Best Musical: Fun Home
Best Play: The Other Place
—
| Award | Winner | Role | Show |
|---|---|---|---|
| INDIVIDUALS IN A MUSICAL | |||
| Best Actress Ensemble (Youth) | Avery Stites | Groundhog | Groundhog Day |
| Best Actress Featured Role (Youth) | Azalea Rodgers | Snow White | Disney’s Descendants |
| Best Actress Supporting Role (Youth) | Italia Zarate | Audrey | Disney’s Descendants |
| Best Actress Lead Role (Youth) | Kaileya de la Serna | Evie | Disney’s Descendants |
| Best Actor Ensemble (Youth) | Keanu de la Serna | Smitten Kid | Disney’s Descendants |
| Best Actor Featured Role (Youth) | Deklan Jenkins | Royal Guard | Disney’s Descendants |
| Best Actor Supporting Role (Youth) | Ben Primrose | Doug | Disney’s Descendants |
| Best Actor Lead Role (Youth) | Sergio Olivas Lara | Jay | Disney’s Descendants |
| Best Actress Ensemble (Teen) | Danée Harper | Ensemble | High School Musical |
| Best Actress Featured Role (Teen) | Ava Meehan | Deputy | Groundhog Day |
| Best Actress Supporting Role (Teen) | Annabella Zambataro | Small Alison | Fun Home |
| Best Actress Lead Role (Teen) | Dara Hargreaves | Leading Player | High School Musical |
| Best Actor Ensemble (Teen) | Lucas Fleischer (tie) | Jason/Zeke Understudy | High School Musical |
| Best Actor Ensemble (Teen) | Cruz Andrade (tie) | Alan/Karaoke MC | High School Musical |
| Best Actor Ensemble (Teen) | Gustavo Cardenes (tie) | James | High School Musical |
| Best Actor Featured Role (Teen) | Miles Casey | Zeke Baylor | High School Musical |
| Best Actor Supporting Role (Teen) | Jude Lee | King Beast | Disney’s Descendants |
| Best Actor Lead Role (Teen) | Graham Bortolussi | Ben | Disney’s Descendants |
| Best Actress Ensemble Role (Adult) | Becky Maguire | Doris | Groundhog Day |
| Best Actress Featured Role (Adult) | Sarah Smith | Piano Teacher | Groundhog Day |
| Best Actress Supporting Role (Adult) | Kaitlyn Scadina | Medium Alison | Fun Home |
| Best Actress Lead Role (Adult) | Katherine Thomassen | Alison | Fun Home |
| Best Actor Ensemble Role (Adult) | Andy Bates | Man in Hall/Healer | Groundhog Day |
| Best Actor Featured Role (Adult) | Ray D’Ambrosio | Buster/Gus | Groundhog Day |
| Best Actor Supporting Role (Adult) | Dylan Bagwell | Ned Ryerson | Groundhog Day |
| Best Actor Lead Role (Adult) | Andrew Stebbins | Phil Connors | Groundhog Day |
| INDIVIDUALS IN A PLAY | |||
| Best Actress Featured / Ensemble Role | Barbara Heninger | Mother/Prostitute/Dress Shop/ssistant | Comic Potential |
| Best Actress Supporting Role | Andy Kline | Debra | Kimberly Akimbo |
| Best Actress Lead Role | Roberta Vinkhuyzen Rasmussen | Juliana | The Other Place |
| Best Actor Featured / Ensemble Role | Billy Tindall | Doctor/Farmer/Dress Shop Man | Comic Potential |
| Best Actor Supporting Role | Peter Mandel | Ian | The Other Place |
| Best Actor Lead Role | Jovan Roberts | Adam Trainsmith | Comic Potential |
| LEGACY ROBE RECIPIENTS | Bella Prak & Mila Aitken | Disney’s Descendants | |
| Lucas Fleischer | High School Musical | ||
| Rachel Stites & Andy Bates | Groundhog Day | ||
| PRODUCERS’ AWARDS | AJ Jaffari, Clara Shem-Tov, Kelly Kobata | Kimberly Akimbo | |
| Josh Rempel | Disney’s Descendants | ||
| Illia Campbell | Fun Home | ||
| Isabelle Polito, Sada Bruhns | The Other Place | ||
| Clara Shem-Tov | High School Musical | ||
| Angie Higgins, Archita Satapathy | Comic Potential | ||
| Peter Mandel | Groundhog Day | ||
| BOARD OF DIRECTORS AWARDS | |||
| Resalie Andrews Tech Award | Clara Shem-Tov | ||
| Outstanding Talent Award | Illia Campbell | ||
| Becky Kaiser Newcomer Award | Jackson Paddock & John Bernard De Leon | ||
| Outstanding Volunteer Service Award | Michael Horta | ||
| STAFF AWARDS – PLAY | |||
| Best Costume Design | Amanda Fitzgerald | Comic Potential | |
| Best Director | Bryan Freeman | The Other Place | |
| STAFF AWARDS – MUSICAL | |||
| Best Choreographer | Natalie Fitzgibbons | High School Musical | |
| Best Vocal Director | Jackson Paddock | Groundhog Day | |
| Best Music Director | Ron Bowman | Fun Home | |
| Best Costume Design | Adrianne Wilkinson | Disney’s Descendants | |
| Best Set & Scenic Design | Jenn Oliphant | High School Musical | |
| Best Director | Tressa Bender | Fun Home | |
| BEST PLAY | The Other Place – Peter Mandel & Emily Shem-Tov, Producers | ||
| BEST MUSICAL | Fun Home – Hayley Allison & Tressa Bender, Producers | ||