2016-2017 Members’ Choice Awards

Best Show: Footloose The Musical (Teen Production)
| Award Type | Winner | Role | Show |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best Male in a Lead Role (Youth) | Gannon Janisch | Prince Eric | Disney’s The Little Mermaid Jr. |
| Best Male in a Supporting Role (Youth) | Paul Maack | King Triton | Disney’s The Little Mermaid Jr. |
| Best Male in a Minor Role (Youth) | Tim Piper | Grimsby | Disney’s The Little Mermaid Jr. |
| Best Male Ensemble (Youth) | Josh Watts | Squawking Seagull | Disney’s The Little Mermaid Jr. |
| Best Female in a Lead Role (Youth) | Emily Pember | Ariel | Disney’s The Little Mermaid Jr. |
| Best Female in a Supporting Role (Youth) | Tegan Leong | Sebastian | Disney’s The Little Mermaid Jr. |
| Best Female in a Minor Role (Youth) | Julia Millward | Chef Luis | Disney’s The Little Mermaid Jr. |
| Best Female Ensemble (Youth) | Avery Dubenko | Alphie/Oompa | Willy Wonka |
| Best Male in a Lead Role (Teen) | Edie Garcia-Flores | Ren McCormack | Footloose: The Musical |
| Best Male in a Supporting Role (Teen) | Ben Snook | Willard Hewitt | Footloose: The Musical |
| Best Male in a Minor Role (Teen) | Carter Sepulveda | Grandpa George | Willy Wonka |
| Best Male Ensemble (Teen) | Carter Sepulveda | Garvin | Footloose: The Musical |
| Best Female in a Lead Role (Teen) | Brianna Pember | Ariel Moore | Footloose: The Musical |
| Best Female in a Supporting Role (Teen) | Paetra Rottman | Vi Moore | Footloose: The Musical |
| Best Female in a Minor Role (Teen) | Rebecca Reynolds | Wendy Jo | Footloose: The Musical |
| Best Female Ensemble (Teen) | Lauren DeRosa | Jeter | Footloose: The Musical |
| Best Male in a Lead Role (Adult) | Scott Lynch | Vanya | Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike |
| Best Male in a Supporting Role (Adult) | Chris Souza | Grandpa Jo | Willy Wonka |
| Best Male in a Minor Role (Adult) | Joe Hartman | Mr. Bucket | Willy Wonka |
| Best Female in a Lead Role (Adult) | Megan Griffin | Ginger Brooks | The 1940’s Radio Hour |
| Best Female in a Supporting Role (Adult) | Roberta Vinkhuyzen | Cassandra | Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike |
| Best Female in a Minor Role (Adult) | Carol Harris | Zoot Doubleman | The 1940’s Radio Hour |
| Gypsy Robe Recipients | Luna Bobeda | Disney’s The Little Mermaid Jr. | |
| Rob Christopher | The 1940’s Radio Hour | ||
| Shalimar McGinnis | Footloose: The Musical | ||
| Scott Lynch | Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike | ||
| Robin Harris & Jennifer Grifall | Willy Wonka | ||
| Producers Awards | Janelle Gallagher & Jason Chamberlain | Disney’s The Little Mermaid Jr. | |
| Joyce Bedard | The 1940’s Radio Hour | ||
| Jarad DeRosa | Footloose: The Musical | ||
| Bridget Harnett | Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike | ||
| Joyce Bedard | Willy Wonka | ||
| Becky Kaiser Newcomer Award | The Oberlander Family | ||
| Rosalie Andrews Tech Award | Roger Traverso | ||
| Al Bloom Shining Star Award | Adrianne Wilkinson | ||
| Best Hair & Makeup | Paige Wilson, Brianna Pember, Lauren DeRosa | Disney’s The Little Mermaid Jr. | |
| Best Set/Scenic Design | Colleen Blanchard, Larry Tom, Jason Leong | Disney’s The Little Mermaid Jr. | |
| Best Costume Design | Alice Gracey | Disney’s The Little Mermaid Jr. | |
| Best Choreographer | Jyovonne Montosa | Footloose: The Musical | |
| Best Music Director | Carol Harris | The 1940’s Radio Hour | |
| Best Vocal Director | Joy Reynolds | Footloose: The Musical | |
| Best Director/Assistant Director | Alan Chipman | Footloose: The Musical | |
| Best Show | Tracy Van Gundy & Marianne Snook, Producers | Footloose: The Musical |